Canine Conditioning and Training: A Reflection on the Mechanisms of Education
In the world of dog training, we often discuss methods, tools, rewards, and reinforcements. But we sometimes forget to revisit the basic psychological mechanisms that govern a dog's learning. In particular, two fundamental types of conditioning deserve to be distinguished: classical (or Pavlovian) conditioning and operant (or Skinnerian) conditioning.
Classical conditioning (Pavlov)
Discovered by Ivan Pavlov, this type of conditioning relies on the unconscious association between a neutral stimulus and an emotional or physiological response. The famous example of Pavlov's dogs salivating at the bell perfectly illustrates this mechanism: the bell, repeatedly paired with the presentation of food, eventually triggers salivation on its own.
In dogs, we use this mechanism constantly without even realizing it. A soft tone of voice, a caress, or a smile from the owner, repeated frequently, can become powerful reinforcers because they are associated with a feeling of well-being. This is not a voluntary action by the dog to obtain something; it is an emotional response to a situation perceived as pleasant.
Operant conditioning (Skinner)
B.F. Skinner described another type of learning: operant conditioning. Here, the animal acts voluntarily to obtain a reward (or avoid punishment). This is the system of positive reinforcements (treats, toys, biting games) and negative reinforcements (removal of unpleasant pressure).
Today, the majority of modern training methods rely heavily on this operant conditioning. The dog is taught to "work" to obtain an external reward: its ball, its food, its sausage, its biting game. These methods work very well technically, and allow for complex and precise behaviors to be achieved.
The risk of a “transactional” relationship
However, this highly effective approach has a limitation: the risk of focusing all of the dog's motivation on the reward object, and not on the relationship with the owner. The dog executes the command to get its ball, not for the pleasure of pleasing its owner.
Now, the dog, as a social animal, descends from a pack animal whose cooperation with the group is a fundamental need.
Used well, Pavlovian conditioning can powerfully reinforce this emotional and social dimension.
A petting, or even an approving look combined with a warm tone of voice, can trigger the release of oxytocin and endorphins in dogs—the hormones of social pleasure and bonding.
The dog then learns that the simple fact of satisfying its master is, in itself, a source of pleasure, even a pleasure greater than that of an external reward (ball, sausage, treat, etc.).
A balance track
Ideally, balanced dog training should integrate both dimensions. Operant conditioning is valuable for learning behaviors. But classical conditioning helps give emotional meaning to these behaviors: pleasing their owner becomes, for the dog, an end in itself.
It is probably on this balance that the best master-dog relationships are based: a dog that works well and above all works for and with its master.
Leave a Reply